Join 30,000+ brand owners, operators and marketers. Subscribe here.
No. 200: Hey all,
Most brands assume that the reason someone chooses a subscription over a one-off purchase is the discount.
“Subscribe and save 20%.”
But shoppers rarely hesitate over the price.
They hesitate over the commitment.
Why subscribe instead of just buying again later?
If the only answer is a discount, many customers won’t commit.
Here’s what actually makes subscription offers convert.
In less than 2 minutes, learn:
Read time: 2 minutes
Thinking about optimizing (or redesigning) your store?
Meet with our expert team and get a free storefront analysis. We'll show you exactly what to change to increase conversions and profit.
🎯 WEEKLY INSIGHT
Subscriptions convert best when the benefits are visible on the page.
On many product pages, the subscription option only highlights the discount – nothing else.
So shoppers don’t know why subscribing is better.
The benefits need to be visible right away.
Let’s take the subscription brand Flakes.
On their product page, the benefits of subscribing aren’t hidden.
They’re presented on the page automatically.
Shoppers can instantly see:
gifts & perks included
how often the product ships
how much they save
what extra value subscribers receive
All directly under the subscription option.
They don’t have to select the subscription first to understand the benefits.
Instead, share the benefits immediately.
Show shoppers exactly what they gain by subscribing.
Add perks like:
flexible delivery timing
priority access to new products
subscriber-only bundles
loyalty benefits or gifts
the ability to skip or adjust shipments
These shift the conversation from:
“I can save 20%” to “Oh, this will actually make my life easier.”
And convenience is what drives subscriptions.
⭐ Takeaway: Don’t hide subscription perks behind a dropdown. Show reasons to subscribe directly on the page so shoppers can evaluate in the moment.
🕙 WHAT’S BREWING
Over 12 months and 36 A/B tests, they generated $1.8 million in incremental revenue
Revising navigation increased mobile conversions 9%
Cutting brand-exposition copy boosted conversions 7.3%
🗞️ NEWS HIGHLIGHT
AI tools now adjust pricing in real time based on demand, competition, and customer behavior
Brands can test and optimize prices faster without manual updates
Pricing is shifting from static to dynamic across products and segments
👀 FROM LAST WEEK
One simple homepage add-on that guides new customers to the right starting point.
Highlight one standout product with add-to-cart directly on the homepage.
It gives browsing visitors an easy place to start purchasing.
If small changes like this can lift conversions double digits, imagine what a full-site strategy could do.
Let’s find your next win → Book a strategy call.
Until next time,
— Allen